I bet it’s also because so many people are ending up with permabans.
I used Reddit since around 2009, Digg before. Posted a lot, but never really got any bans until the last couple of years despite my tone not changing. There also seems to be a Reddit AI which reads and judges every post before anyone sees it, where it can suspend you at a whim. A few suspensions results in a permaban, device/IP wide as it took out my alts of 10-15 years.
So many subs have mod filters or restrict conversations in all sorts of creative ways.
And that results in a boring place. The only way to not be banned is to be super boring, or be a bot. So boring people and bots are going to be the main crowd still posting there.
Everything is so locked down nowadays. It’s crazy to think how free we were over a decade ago. When PHP bulletin forums were still a thing, and the average internet user was serious about open discussions and mocking the idea of things like the cyber police.
But seriously, Reddit is banning a lot of people who have stuck around since near the beginning. As far as I’m concerned it deserves to die now and let something new take its place.
Also, in my ad free version of the Reddit app, recently they seem to have started rate limiting it so after loading a few things it stops working for like 5 minutes. Feels hostile.
Not to mention, that once you’re banned from Reddit, and even if you are able to make a new account, the site restricts new accounts massively and they tell you you have to post in the boring subs for karma like a job before your account is allowed to post in anything that Reddit doesn’t think of advertiser friendly. And it’s all hidden away well, so new users of Reddit may never find it and stick to the “safe” subs.
I’ve seen subs that were once very active becoming inactive with only a few regular posters yet. And there’s no way to give them the message since Reddit has so many layers of AI, filters and shadowbans preventing it.
Reddit has analytics MUCH deeper than device ID/IP.
I’ve actually tested this theory when I got my new phone. Made a new (test) Apple account, didn’t join my WiFi, it was a brand new SIM card, so aside from rough location + nearby networks, nothing really tied to me.
Registered a Reddit account. Took them less than 24 hours to take it down claiming the same exact bullshit (ban evasion) as they did when they banned my OC.
they do canvas fingerprinting, they use V2/V3 CAPTCHA to track your mouse movements, look your telemetry data, like some of your device components, time zone. they track how you scroll and how long your scroll or comment in an sub.
I’ve used different devices, different emails, and a few other things and it doesn’t matter. Within 24 hours I’m banned for ban evasion. I don’t even know how they know it’s me.
It wouldn’t be so bad if there was actually a good alternative to Reddit,.but there really isn’t. Lemmy is close, but doesn’t have nearly the amount of communities.
It’s close though. There’s an inflection point in users and lemmy is pretty close, like probably just needs to 3-5x it’s current user base and it’ll really explode, although all the fragmentation doesn’t help.
people went from forums, qoura, Y/answers to reddit it was the death of the other communities. forums was too restrictive and reddit had an answer for that, but now reddit is arbitrary restrictive.
They can fingerprint a user based on their online activity (just sites visited, I think) with 90+% accuracy. There was a paper on it. Didn’t think much of it, but then I became aware that I also open the tabs in the same order every time too.
I bet it’s also because so many people are ending up with permabans.
I used Reddit since around 2009, Digg before. Posted a lot, but never really got any bans until the last couple of years despite my tone not changing. There also seems to be a Reddit AI which reads and judges every post before anyone sees it, where it can suspend you at a whim. A few suspensions results in a permaban, device/IP wide as it took out my alts of 10-15 years.
So many subs have mod filters or restrict conversations in all sorts of creative ways.
And that results in a boring place. The only way to not be banned is to be super boring, or be a bot. So boring people and bots are going to be the main crowd still posting there.
Everything is so locked down nowadays. It’s crazy to think how free we were over a decade ago. When PHP bulletin forums were still a thing, and the average internet user was serious about open discussions and mocking the idea of things like the cyber police.
But seriously, Reddit is banning a lot of people who have stuck around since near the beginning. As far as I’m concerned it deserves to die now and let something new take its place.
Also, in my ad free version of the Reddit app, recently they seem to have started rate limiting it so after loading a few things it stops working for like 5 minutes. Feels hostile.
Not to mention, that once you’re banned from Reddit, and even if you are able to make a new account, the site restricts new accounts massively and they tell you you have to post in the boring subs for karma like a job before your account is allowed to post in anything that Reddit doesn’t think of advertiser friendly. And it’s all hidden away well, so new users of Reddit may never find it and stick to the “safe” subs.
I’ve seen subs that were once very active becoming inactive with only a few regular posters yet. And there’s no way to give them the message since Reddit has so many layers of AI, filters and shadowbans preventing it.
Bit of a rant. Just been a little annoyed by it.
Reddit has analytics MUCH deeper than device ID/IP.
I’ve actually tested this theory when I got my new phone. Made a new (test) Apple account, didn’t join my WiFi, it was a brand new SIM card, so aside from rough location + nearby networks, nothing really tied to me.
Registered a Reddit account. Took them less than 24 hours to take it down claiming the same exact bullshit (ban evasion) as they did when they banned my OC.
they do canvas fingerprinting, they use V2/V3 CAPTCHA to track your mouse movements, look your telemetry data, like some of your device components, time zone. they track how you scroll and how long your scroll or comment in an sub.
I’ve used different devices, different emails, and a few other things and it doesn’t matter. Within 24 hours I’m banned for ban evasion. I don’t even know how they know it’s me.
I think they fingerprint your behaviour, location, and any metadata they can mine from the phone.
Same subreddits, same style of talking, same location, same WiFi networks, Bluetooth beacons etc. nearby = same user, ban.
they also do bulk bans to, if your behaviour similar to other accounts that have been flagged you get caught in the mess too.
Honestly, that shouldn’t even be legal if you ask me. Like, I could understand if I’d actually done something bad, but I didn’t.
I fully agree. This level of privacy invasion is disgusting.
It wouldn’t be so bad if there was actually a good alternative to Reddit,.but there really isn’t. Lemmy is close, but doesn’t have nearly the amount of communities.
It’s close though. There’s an inflection point in users and lemmy is pretty close, like probably just needs to 3-5x it’s current user base and it’ll really explode, although all the fragmentation doesn’t help.
people went from forums, qoura, Y/answers to reddit it was the death of the other communities. forums was too restrictive and reddit had an answer for that, but now reddit is arbitrary restrictive.
They can fingerprint a user based on their online activity (just sites visited, I think) with 90+% accuracy. There was a paper on it. Didn’t think much of it, but then I became aware that I also open the tabs in the same order every time too.