I agree, but it’s unfortunately within the scope of the law. They will argue the confinement was necessary to prevent ongoing misconduct. It’s blatant extrajudicial punishment, but our system is very lenient for these types of things in the State’s favor.
Yes. So we should provide sources lest we propagate non-sense.
I’ve got a separate set of comments on this post where I do that. Because I’m trying to understand why this case has differed from my own experience with these issues while I was in the military.
UCMJ article 13. This is arguably within those very lenient lines. Can be held for up to 120 days before trial. Again, it’s legal, and that’s the problem. The confinement is punitive and it is more than is necessary. It should be illegal. Unfortunately, the interpretation of the law is up to those that benefit from its loosest interpretation. They’ll argue that this confinement is necessary because they need to prevent additional harm (the speech the officer used). It’s BS, but as long as those enforcing the law accept that lame excuse, it’s legal.
I mentioned the 120 days in the other thread because you made an argument that people have been held for years pre-trial under the UCMJ, which I can’t find any examples of.
You’re SUPPOSING a bunch of things COULD happen without providing examples/sources. I want examples/sources.
I think the sticking point is:
I’m arguing that they’re willing to commit illegal acts against this man, because this admin is willing to do illegal things.
You are arguing that they are operating loosely within the bounds of the law, and therefore, legal.
We both agree that it’s fucked. Neither of us is a lawyer.
I mentioned the 120 days in the other thread because you made an argument that people have been held for years pre-trial under the UCMJ, which I can’t find any examples of.
You’re SUPPOSING a bunch of things COULD happen without providing examples/sources. I want examples/sources.
I think the sticking point is:
I’m arguing that they’re willing to commit illegal acts against this man, because this admin is willing to do illegal things.
You are arguing that they are operating loosely within the bounds of the law, and therefore, legal.
We both agree that it’s fucked. Neither of us is a lawyer.
But it isn’t legal though.
He can be court martialed. He can see criminal charges.
They skipped straight to torture.
I agree, but it’s unfortunately within the scope of the law. They will argue the confinement was necessary to prevent ongoing misconduct. It’s blatant extrajudicial punishment, but our system is very lenient for these types of things in the State’s favor.
You keep saying these things like you’re a lawyer? The point of the article is that it’s NOT in the scope of the law to do what they’re doing…
Can you please provide any sources?
Unless one of us is a military lawyer, all of our opinions hold equal weight.
Yes. So we should provide sources lest we propagate non-sense.
I’ve got a separate set of comments on this post where I do that. Because I’m trying to understand why this case has differed from my own experience with these issues while I was in the military.
UCMJ article 13. This is arguably within those very lenient lines. Can be held for up to 120 days before trial. Again, it’s legal, and that’s the problem. The confinement is punitive and it is more than is necessary. It should be illegal. Unfortunately, the interpretation of the law is up to those that benefit from its loosest interpretation. They’ll argue that this confinement is necessary because they need to prevent additional harm (the speech the officer used). It’s BS, but as long as those enforcing the law accept that lame excuse, it’s legal.
I mentioned the 120 days in the other thread because you made an argument that people have been held for years pre-trial under the UCMJ, which I can’t find any examples of.
You’re SUPPOSING a bunch of things COULD happen without providing examples/sources. I want examples/sources.
I think the sticking point is:
I’m arguing that they’re willing to commit illegal acts against this man, because this admin is willing to do illegal things.
You are arguing that they are operating loosely within the bounds of the law, and therefore, legal.
We both agree that it’s fucked. Neither of us is a lawyer.
I mentioned the 120 days in the other thread because you made an argument that people have been held for years pre-trial under the UCMJ, which I can’t find any examples of.
You’re SUPPOSING a bunch of things COULD happen without providing examples/sources. I want examples/sources.
I think the sticking point is:
I’m arguing that they’re willing to commit illegal acts against this man, because this admin is willing to do illegal things.
You are arguing that they are operating loosely within the bounds of the law, and therefore, legal.
We both agree that it’s fucked. Neither of us is a lawyer.