I sorta get the shooting thing, though the actual risk is so vanishingly rare that it shouldn’t be a thing they plan for. Also, we don’t want kids to have phones during an emergency like a shooting because they jam up emergency services/phone lines and it keeps them from effectively following instructions that could keep them safe.
And on the independence front, they’re absolutely tethered to their folks. So many parents have tracking apps on and are constantly keeping tabs on their kids’ locations. I personally know multiple kids whose parents have showed up at minor car accidents before emergency services because they’re just watching the kid dot on the tracking map. Plus, kids almost all share their locations with their friends and are socially expected to be available on whatever app.
So many kids growing up with smartphones are functionally never alone and you can see the anxiety it breeds.
I sorta get the shooting thing, though the actual risk is so vanishingly rare that it shouldn’t be a thing they plan for. Also, we don’t want kids to have phones during an emergency like a shooting because they jam up emergency services/phone lines and it keeps them from effectively following instructions that could keep them safe.
And on the independence front, they’re absolutely tethered to their folks. So many parents have tracking apps on and are constantly keeping tabs on their kids’ locations. I personally know multiple kids whose parents have showed up at minor car accidents before emergency services because they’re just watching the kid dot on the tracking map. Plus, kids almost all share their locations with their friends and are socially expected to be available on whatever app.
So many kids growing up with smartphones are functionally never alone and you can see the anxiety it breeds.