This is a good example of confirmation bias in action.
Let’s be clear about what this article actually reports. One study, examining 3.3 million students across approximately 4,600 schools, identified modest improvements in academic performance associated with strict cellphone restrictions. The estimated improvement amounted to roughly one to two additional weeks of instruction per academic year.
That’s hardly the educational revolution some people in this comment section seem to think it is.
More importantly, this is not a settled scientific conclusion. The article itself acknowledges that another major study, published through the National Bureau of Economic Research, found that the average effects of cellphone bans on academic achievement were consistently close to zero. It identified modest improvements in some high school mathematics results, but also small negative effects in middle schools.
A separate international review of 22 studies found that the evidence was limited, inconsistent, and lacking randomized controlled trials. Several studies found no relationship between phone bans and academic achievement whatsoever.
The problem here is that people appear to have already decided that banning phones improves education, and they are treating any research that supports that belief as confirmation while conveniently ignoring research that contradicts it.
There is also a fundamental distinction between identifying a statistical association and establishing a meaningful causal relationship. Even when a study identifies an improvement following a policy change, that does not automatically establish that the policy itself was responsible for the improvement, much less that the effect is substantial or generalizable.
I’m not arguing that students should spend their school day scrolling through TikTok. Obviously, phones can be distracting. I’m arguing that we should distinguish between a policy that sounds intuitively reasonable and one that has actually demonstrated measurable educational benefits.
So far, the broader research does not support the certainty with which some people are advocating these bans. A small, inconsistent improvement in some studies is not proof that banning phones meaningfully improves academic performance.
Read the research, not just the headline. And perhaps consider whether you’re evaluating the evidence objectively or simply looking for studies that validate what you’ve already decided to believe.
Yeah, in the end, if someone is gonna get distracted with the phone, i assure you that they are gonna get distracted even without, be it just fiddling, doodling or looking at the void
For anyone reading this, the NBER study actually found that it DID improve scores, but declared otherwise because they’re a private think tank that literally just says whatever corporations pay them to. They have a long and storied history of providing pro-corpo ‘studies.’
Do you happen to know of studies that look at places that removed all screen-based teaching from schools? I remember reading some articles about the issue being not just phones, but also using laptops and tablets as teaching devices. Perhaps more screens than just phones should be banned/limited for there to be a significant effect.
Honestly, agreed. Even as an adult, I find trying to learn new material on a screen somewhat difficult, considering how extremely easy it is to jump tabs to something less challenging.
This is a good example of confirmation bias in action.
Let’s be clear about what this article actually reports. One study, examining 3.3 million students across approximately 4,600 schools, identified modest improvements in academic performance associated with strict cellphone restrictions. The estimated improvement amounted to roughly one to two additional weeks of instruction per academic year.
That’s hardly the educational revolution some people in this comment section seem to think it is.
More importantly, this is not a settled scientific conclusion. The article itself acknowledges that another major study, published through the National Bureau of Economic Research, found that the average effects of cellphone bans on academic achievement were consistently close to zero. It identified modest improvements in some high school mathematics results, but also small negative effects in middle schools.
A separate international review of 22 studies found that the evidence was limited, inconsistent, and lacking randomized controlled trials. Several studies found no relationship between phone bans and academic achievement whatsoever.
The problem here is that people appear to have already decided that banning phones improves education, and they are treating any research that supports that belief as confirmation while conveniently ignoring research that contradicts it.
There is also a fundamental distinction between identifying a statistical association and establishing a meaningful causal relationship. Even when a study identifies an improvement following a policy change, that does not automatically establish that the policy itself was responsible for the improvement, much less that the effect is substantial or generalizable.
I’m not arguing that students should spend their school day scrolling through TikTok. Obviously, phones can be distracting. I’m arguing that we should distinguish between a policy that sounds intuitively reasonable and one that has actually demonstrated measurable educational benefits.
So far, the broader research does not support the certainty with which some people are advocating these bans. A small, inconsistent improvement in some studies is not proof that banning phones meaningfully improves academic performance.
Read the research, not just the headline. And perhaps consider whether you’re evaluating the evidence objectively or simply looking for studies that validate what you’ve already decided to believe.
Yeah, in the end, if someone is gonna get distracted with the phone, i assure you that they are gonna get distracted even without, be it just fiddling, doodling or looking at the void
For anyone reading this, the NBER study actually found that it DID improve scores, but declared otherwise because they’re a private think tank that literally just says whatever corporations pay them to. They have a long and storied history of providing pro-corpo ‘studies.’
Do you happen to know of studies that look at places that removed all screen-based teaching from schools? I remember reading some articles about the issue being not just phones, but also using laptops and tablets as teaching devices. Perhaps more screens than just phones should be banned/limited for there to be a significant effect.
Honestly, agreed. Even as an adult, I find trying to learn new material on a screen somewhat difficult, considering how extremely easy it is to jump tabs to something less challenging.