• 0 Posts
  • 31 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 21st, 2026

help-circle



  • The supreme court is an illegitimate institution that regularly declares itself arbiter of things it has no business in. It has effectively become first among “equals” in a government of increasingly questionable legitimacy. Doesn’t matter whether they do something “good” or “bad” we shouldn’t view them as having any legitimate authority in the first place – Certainly not in elections.

    Today they have a voice in gerrymandering. Tomorrow? Will they declare lottery elections illegitimate? More Money is speech nonsense? Can’t Tax political donations? Can’t tax political advertising? There are ways to make the government legitimate and give it consent of the governed – but we cannot allow corrupt oligarchs to tell us what is and isn’t legitimate.









  • There really need to be safeguards implemented to prevent actions like this from just being conducted on the turn of a dime without any awareness of others, discussion, etc. beforehand.

    These systems and safeguards exist, but they remain inactive due to political capture and entrenchment. You can make all the laws you like, but they mean nothing when oligarch rule prevents enforcement or encourages inconsistent enforcement.

    This is what I’m talking about when I say we’re not close enough to qualifying as a democracy for me to approve of our interference in foreign affairs. The people do not rule in the United States. We’re not a democratic republic, we’re an electoral oligarchy.

    Worse, we seem to be choosing this. States choose how their elections work. We could switch to a ranked voting system with a lottery option without the federal government being able to do anything about it. Heck, a lot of individual cities could do it, but people aren’t engaged enough to overcome local entrenched powers much less state and federal ones.