According to witnesses, a male firefighter helping Hunter stopped and backed away laughing upon discovering that she had a penis, and saying “this bitch ain’t no girl…it’s a n*****, he’s got a dick”.
Two other witnesses corroborated the comment, but the description of the technician varied. He continued derogatory comments and joking with other firefighters while leaving her untreated.
Bystanders requested them to resume treatment, but they did not do so until a supervisor arrived three to seven minutes later.
[…]
ER staff at subsequently "failed to diagnose Hunter’s injuries and follow nationally accepted standards of care."Hunter died about an hour after arriving, and two hours after the crash


doesn’t apply here.
The paradox is about defending the institutions of open society against movements that reject reasoned persuasion and seek power through coercion or violence. The “intolerant” in the paradox are not merely intolerant in the everyday sense. They are intolerant[1] of the open society itself.
The original passage that articulated it
was in a footnote in the political philosophy book The Open Society and Its Enemies by Karl Popper.
An open society is governed through nonviolent political competition that depends on free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate. Consequently, someone may hold repugnant, exclusionary views and still remain within the framework of an open society, provided they continue to accept nonviolent public choice and the institutions that sustain it. Such a person is not the target of the paradox.
Rather, those who violate the framework of an open society by suppressing the conditions it depends on (free inquiry, intellectual liberty, open debate) are closer to the target of the paradox.
Popper’s argument is not about silencing disagreeable beliefs as social media commonly claims. Open society can consistently tolerate a wide range of beliefs while refusing to tolerate violations of conditions that make tolerance possible. Since we aren’t specifically talking about such violators, the paradox simply doesn’t apply here.
Tolerance in political philosophy more strictly means the acceptance of an objectionable idea or practice. Intolerance more strictly means the rejection of such idea or practice. A society rejects by prohibiting. A movement rejects a society by violating or suppressing its conditions of existence (or norms). ↩︎