According to witnesses, a male firefighter helping Hunter stopped and backed away laughing upon discovering that she had a penis, and saying “this bitch ain’t no girl…it’s a n*****, he’s got a dick”.
Two other witnesses corroborated the comment, but the description of the technician varied. He continued derogatory comments and joking with other firefighters while leaving her untreated.
Bystanders requested them to resume treatment, but they did not do so until a supervisor arrived three to seven minutes later.
[…]
ER staff at subsequently "failed to diagnose Hunter’s injuries and follow nationally accepted standards of care."Hunter died about an hour after arriving, and two hours after the crash


Of course not. They did nothing wrong. It was just a trans girl not a person
Would you please explain your comment?
I missed the s at the end
I’m still learning and asking genuinely: can you be trans without going through all the surgeries and hormone supplements? Like is it a thing in the community for a seemingly biological man to be considered trans through lifestyle changes?
Yes. A lot of people don’t have the option for hormones or surgery for various reasons, or choose not to use those options for various reasons. But a trans person is trans regardless.
Moreover, still a person and should be treated as such.
So what’s the difference between transexual and transgender? I always thought that the first one required all the treatments and the second one not.
So transgender is an umbrella term collecting everyone who’s gender identity doesn’t match the sex they were assigned at birth. Transsexual is predominantly an outdated term that was replaced by transgender to give it distance from words like homosexual and bisexual. But some modern trans people (including myself) use the term for ourselves to further differentiate those of us who have pursued and undergone medical transition.
Within those who use it there are varying definitions, some argue you need to have undergone both hormones and bottom surgery (and top surgery for transmasculine people), others say you only need to want it, or that you only need some amount of it. Similarly some restrict the identity to binary people, others don’t. I’m loose on all these fronts, and largely use it because those of us who pursue medical transition do have distinct needs that those who don’t don’t have.
Usually “sex” is defined chromosonally, and “gender” is socially.
So literally transgender means your current social expression of male vs female isnt static. Literally transexual would mean something like replacing XY’s Y chromosome with another X somehow.
Back in the day they were used interchangeably, so those socially representing as the other gender were called transexual.
Nowadays you’ll really only hear transgender, as chromosomal replacement still doesn’t yet exist, but usually people mean the same thing when using either.
HRT/surgeries are just a common method of expressing gender, but not inheritly linked to it in any concrete way. On average this improves the mental health of the trans patient, so its usually represented in a positive light - but its far from essential to the trans experience.
Legally requiring surgeries/HRT to be recognised is a common method to restrict the growth of trans communities (the usual union busing-adjacent shit).
Oh, TIL.
Thanks! Genuinely. 🤗
Edir: I hope genetical replacement comes soon! That would be really cool as someone who loves science haha 🤭
Sex is not generally defined chromosomally in the trans community, we’re some of the biggest ones pushing back against that idea
Furthermore, changing chromosomes would do very little except impede transphobes who’d just jump to another line anyways.
Yeah, us biologists aren’t too keen on chromosomes=sex thing either.
Thank you for clarifying!
The distinction you’re looking for is social vs medical transition; someone who transitions socially may change their name, pronouns, and how they dress, while people who medically transition take hormones and/or have gender related surgery.
Thank you. This is what I’m looking for that makes sense to me.
You can change your appearance a lot with clothes, letting your hair grow, cutting your body hair
There is also the fact that a lot of trans people are unable or choose not to medically transition because of laws, parents, society, medical issues, they dont see it necessary, are nonbinary, etc.
This person is obviously not learning asking genuinely but a bad faith actor looking for an opportunity to push trans medicalist bullshit. I’m just saying, it’s weird this comment is even here.
Pretty sure that’s not the case here. People learn best by asking direct questions. They’ll struggle to do better if asking questions gets them accused of pushing a hateful agenda despite their best attempts at being respectful.
I get it. A lot of online hate starts as “just asking questions”, but not everyone asking questions goes down that path. The only way for this person to avoid the faux pas they committed is to understand more about the subject they’re specifically asking about.
Perhaps consider giving those like them the opportunity to show their intent through further communication before making accusations based on assumptions?
I literally don’t even know what trans medicalist bullshit means.
I am absolutely being genuine and have no idea how you’re coming up with your comment.
There are genuine people in this world and its easier for me to here because people like you in real life go off thinking a person trying to learn as an ally is an enemy.
They are a reactionary looking for a fight. Everyone should block people like this because all they do is make Lemmy worse.
Thanks Trick, I’ve definitely seen your name before because I always chortle at it lol
I try to stay on the fence for some issues so I’ll block them if it becomes just a fight.
I’m not looking to fight, just learn and enjoy a better social media platform.
Yeah, I always used to give people the benefit of doubt, but after so many times of getting stuck in a pointless argument where everything I say is twisted to prove I’m the bad guy, I changed over to just blocking when such a red flag occurs. I got an angry combative response from this user myself just a few minutes ago.
Well as you can see from naïve or uneducated questions (as some might say) I’m still new and figuring it out.
I may some day get to your point but for the sake of my “on the fence” approach, I like to hear both side of most issues.
What I am saying is TRUE. You aren’t an ally if you call me a fucking biological male and you’re definitely not an ally if you block me for calling that out.
You people are so fucking evil I swear to fucking god. Am I the only one not allowed to enjoy??? Do I have to get called a fucking man while yall get to frolic and thats the ONLY deal or I am a reactionary trying to ruin YOUR day? You can just say WHATEVER about trans people and I have to sit down and shut up about it???
You’re obviously hurting, but you need to realize you’re taking it out on the wrong people. One dude asked some questions and I said stick to the evidence. Neither of these things is indicative of being evil. This is a huge overreaction.
Yeah. Also, biology is immutable once the fetus is completely formed. They’re a girl, yeah, but that doesn’t changes anything about their biology, they’re still biologically male (and medically speaking, they need most of the male-specific treatments) as they’re on that part of the spectrum (genetically, fenotipically and hormonally wise, at least; remember that sex is a bimodal spectrum).
I don’t understand why or how someone can be so science-denialist, so antiscience.
That’s really fucked up honestly, I’m absolutely not that
You aren’t my ally if you call people biological men or males for not having bottom surgery. I doubt you will stop after this even, because you are the one acting in bad faith.
I’m not really sure what you mean, I didn’t call anyone anything. But I did learn something about the trans community despite your aggressiveness.
Many people want to learn more and engage but find it can be a bit off putting with angry people like you.
Regardless, I hope you are well and have a good day.
What you said was hurtful ok. What everyone is saying is extremely harmful. I quit. I’m sorry I ever talked to anyone here I hate it here :(
Not everyone has your frame of reference, your experiences, your sensitivities (not in a bad way). While it’s understandable to pre-judge based on expectations, do you see the irony here? Instead of attacking the person, simply explain the harm. Even if they were a troll, treat it as an opportunity to reach all of the others who are reading the comments.
A lot of people on Lemmy are shitty, yes. I mean it’s a low percentage but it’s enough to be disheartening. I didn’t read every comment here but I haven’t seen anyone saying anything harmful. I see you reading my words and this user’s words as implying other things that you won’t accept might not be our thoughts or intents. It feels like you’re looking for bad intent even if you cannot actually find it.
If you reread my original comment, I added the word “seemingly” because I was just trying to be careful so not to hurt anyone’s feelings.
I just wanted clarify what another user said Social vs. Medical but both are trans.
Why is it harmful? Like, you’re of that sex, regardless of your gender.