GPS satellites would probably be fine. They’re ~50-100x higher in a very different orbit. If you were a giant standing on the surface of earth and the GPS satellites were just over your head, Low Earth Orbit would be skimming the tops of your toes.
Don’t get me wrong, you can absolutely nuke GEO but it would be somewhat harder, take a lot longer (someone may notice you trying to put a fucking nuke through a hohmann transfer) and take out far fewer satellites of military importance.
Also, the military is currently adopting systems that provide GNSS through various terrestrial means (APNT) and your phone already has a the ability to navigate without GNSS by using a database of wifi access points.
I believe its also not a coincidence that GPS is in MEO. The GPS program didn’t start until 1973 and the entire program was a result of the desire for ICBMs to have precise navigation. Since the LEO test was done prior, they would have been able to venture a guess as to a safer orbit for the system.
GPS satellites would probably be fine. They’re ~50-100x higher in a very different orbit. If you were a giant standing on the surface of earth and the GPS satellites were just over your head, Low Earth Orbit would be skimming the tops of your toes.
Don’t get me wrong, you can absolutely nuke GEO but it would be somewhat harder, take a lot longer (someone may notice you trying to put a fucking nuke through a hohmann transfer) and take out far fewer satellites of military importance.
Also, the military is currently adopting systems that provide GNSS through various terrestrial means (APNT) and your phone already has a the ability to navigate without GNSS by using a database of wifi access points.
gps sats are not in geostationary orbit
dsmac and tercom have been around for decades, some systems can also use star position for navigation
GPS satellites are in MEO, about 20,000 km up. That’s still a lot higher than LEO.
I believe its also not a coincidence that GPS is in MEO. The GPS program didn’t start until 1973 and the entire program was a result of the desire for ICBMs to have precise navigation. Since the LEO test was done prior, they would have been able to venture a guess as to a safer orbit for the system.