Maybe an unpopular take, but get your password managers out of the cloud and fully offline. Along with whatever else you deem critical. Things ain’t getting better before they getting far worse IMO
I recently told my dad to go back to the Cellulose password manager as his main, because everything was getting too difficult for him. Looks like I won’t be far behind.
At first this sounds quite perfect offline solution, but have you mentally walked thru some disaster scenarios?
Fire/flood/tornado - Is there an off site copy?
Death - Will someone need access and able/read understand our notes to settle estate for example? My writing is horrific lol
Theft - Minimal, highly unlikely, but…
Habits - Are true strong passwords being used? Typing those in manually each time has to be a nightmare. Leading to habits of use of weak/repetitive passwords. Or storing passwords in the browser.
Not criticizing at all, whatever works for ones situation, and they are all different including ones risk level. And great to see folks putting it thru the grinder.
At the end of the day, nobody else will be there to care if your critical data is lost, only you. Cheers!
Yeah I originally got him using a password manager because of the risk of fire, flood, rats eating the book ect.
Now that I have him using the book again, we have worked out a backup method that works. I keep a copy of his book with me, and update it whenever I visit him. High latency, but it works.
Maaan, I hope you’re wrong about this. Aside from device syncing, I really like knowing that all my data could be restored if my house burns down. I don’t have a second location to store a remote offsite backup of my critical data.
You absolutely do have a second location. Do full disk encryption on a backup drive or two, and ask a friend or colleague to keep it in their house for you - or keep it in a desk at work - or both. occasionally exchange for a fresh backup. Also, fire-hardened safe storage exists, where backup media could survive 30-60 minutes in a house fire
I just put this on my to do list last week, and only just started looking into it. There are cloud based solutions for offsite backup such as Backblaze. I think one way is to set up an script that takes your irreplaceable data locally, encrypts it, and uploads it to backblaze B2 encrypted and immutable for 30 days, which also protects against ransomware.
Alternatively, a friend or family member with decent internet who is willing to let you plug in an affordable NAS at their house.
I’ve used rclone with Backblaze B2 and it’s very good. But I’ve never liked the idea of encrypting locally before backing up to the cloud, all the tools I’ve looked into just seem very complex and I’m not sure I trust them not to corrupt my data somehow or make it impossible to decrypt.
I set it up several years ago and have not had an issue
If you’re worried about hosting public facing services, then put all of your devices on a VPN (Tailscale/Headscale, for example) and only host on the VPN’s network.
I do have everything setup for Tailscale, I’d probably need a different device I’m assuming though because my current “server” has lots of public facing services already. Unless I setup a vm or something?
IMO use a dedicated offline password manager such as KeePassXC, DX for android, etc. Create an emergency sheet (with any password manager) to ensure you never lock yourself out of your own vault (the biggest reason for loss of access)
Offline is not as convenient, in particular for multiple devices, and everybody must make their own risk assessment vs convenience. Just my opinion, but some things are worth have fully under your own control, it has brought me good peace of mind having moved mine offline about 18 months ago.
Don’t panic move, take small steps. Load the app & play with it first, test your backup routine, import one of your backups to test it works properly. Duplicate a few passwords over and try for some time, soon it will become second nature.
Keep your existing manager in place until fully comfortable. If you can, create backups of your existing manager also before you uninstall, leaving yourself some breadcrumbs back in case
You have full control, but also you are solely repsonsible for backups :)
What’s about hardware solution such as Yubikey? This looks pretty newt for me. However, our big company isn‘t using it.
I‘m not deep in it. Curious and seriously interested.
Hardware keys are a good solution (I use one), but need to be kept unplugged from your computer until you need it. It’s easy to plug it in and forget about it. Also, it’s advisable to have an extra one as your backup in case it gets stolen.
Have you considered self hosting a password manager like the community version of Bitwarden on your own server or VPS, this way you get the benefit of a always online server without depending on a external third party
Yes, because browsers run JavaScript and that’s where a lot of the vulnerabilities are coming from. The attack surface of a browser is gargantuan compared to the attack surface of a single-purpose password app that runs only locally.
Maybe an unpopular take, but get your password managers out of the cloud and fully offline. Along with whatever else you deem critical. Things ain’t getting better before they getting far worse IMO
I recently told my dad to go back to the Cellulose password manager as his main, because everything was getting too difficult for him. Looks like I won’t be far behind.
you mean pen and paper?
Yeah, a lil black notebook.
At first this sounds quite perfect offline solution, but have you mentally walked thru some disaster scenarios?
Fire/flood/tornado - Is there an off site copy?
Death - Will someone need access and able/read understand our notes to settle estate for example? My writing is horrific lol
Theft - Minimal, highly unlikely, but…
Habits - Are true strong passwords being used? Typing those in manually each time has to be a nightmare. Leading to habits of use of weak/repetitive passwords. Or storing passwords in the browser.
Not criticizing at all, whatever works for ones situation, and they are all different including ones risk level. And great to see folks putting it thru the grinder.
At the end of the day, nobody else will be there to care if your critical data is lost, only you. Cheers!
Yeah I originally got him using a password manager because of the risk of fire, flood, rats eating the book ect.
Now that I have him using the book again, we have worked out a backup method that works. I keep a copy of his book with me, and update it whenever I visit him. High latency, but it works.
Maaan, I hope you’re wrong about this. Aside from device syncing, I really like knowing that all my data could be restored if my house burns down. I don’t have a second location to store a remote offsite backup of my critical data.
You absolutely do have a second location. Do full disk encryption on a backup drive or two, and ask a friend or colleague to keep it in their house for you - or keep it in a desk at work - or both. occasionally exchange for a fresh backup. Also, fire-hardened safe storage exists, where backup media could survive 30-60 minutes in a house fire
I just put this on my to do list last week, and only just started looking into it. There are cloud based solutions for offsite backup such as Backblaze. I think one way is to set up an script that takes your irreplaceable data locally, encrypts it, and uploads it to backblaze B2 encrypted and immutable for 30 days, which also protects against ransomware.
Alternatively, a friend or family member with decent internet who is willing to let you plug in an affordable NAS at their house.
I’ve used rclone with Backblaze B2 and it’s very good. But I’ve never liked the idea of encrypting locally before backing up to the cloud, all the tools I’ve looked into just seem very complex and I’m not sure I trust them not to corrupt my data somehow or make it impossible to decrypt.
Or host it on your own server, but then you have to put in the work to make sure it’s secure or your in the same mess
What if I just move to selfhosting? I just have too many devices to be able to not have syncing for my passwords
Syncthing + KeepassXC
I set it up several years ago and have not had an issue
If you’re worried about hosting public facing services, then put all of your devices on a VPN (Tailscale/Headscale, for example) and only host on the VPN’s network.
I do have everything setup for Tailscale, I’d probably need a different device I’m assuming though because my current “server” has lots of public facing services already. Unless I setup a vm or something?
You can set Syncthing to only bind to a specific IP address, set that to your Tailscale interface and you’re good to go.
Even from browsers?
IMO use a dedicated offline password manager such as KeePassXC, DX for android, etc. Create an emergency sheet (with any password manager) to ensure you never lock yourself out of your own vault (the biggest reason for loss of access)
Bitwarden has a good one https://bitwarden.com/resources/bitwarden-security-readiness-kit/
Offline is not as convenient, in particular for multiple devices, and everybody must make their own risk assessment vs convenience. Just my opinion, but some things are worth have fully under your own control, it has brought me good peace of mind having moved mine offline about 18 months ago.
At minimal worth spending some time looking into
I’ve been putting it off. It’s such a massive undertaking. But I guess it must be done.
Thanks.
Fucking assholes.
Don’t panic move, take small steps. Load the app & play with it first, test your backup routine, import one of your backups to test it works properly. Duplicate a few passwords over and try for some time, soon it will become second nature.
Keep your existing manager in place until fully comfortable. If you can, create backups of your existing manager also before you uninstall, leaving yourself some breadcrumbs back in case
You have full control, but also you are solely repsonsible for backups :)
Good luck whatever you decide
Thanks mate 👍
What’s about hardware solution such as Yubikey? This looks pretty newt for me. However, our big company isn‘t using it. I‘m not deep in it. Curious and seriously interested.
Hardware keys are a good solution (I use one), but need to be kept unplugged from your computer until you need it. It’s easy to plug it in and forget about it. Also, it’s advisable to have an extra one as your backup in case it gets stolen.
If you prefer open source, check out https://www.nitrokey.com/
Have you considered self hosting a password manager like the community version of Bitwarden on your own server or VPS, this way you get the benefit of a always online server without depending on a external third party
Yes, because browsers run JavaScript and that’s where a lot of the vulnerabilities are coming from. The attack surface of a browser is gargantuan compared to the attack surface of a single-purpose password app that runs only locally.
If they’re synced yes
deleted by creator